Summary
Karen and Tom Krupp are happy–they’ve got a lovely home in upstate New York, they’re practically newlyweds, and they have no kids to interrupt their comfortable life together. But one day, Tom returns home to find Karen has vanished–her car’s gone and it seems she left in a rush. She even left her purse–complete with phone and i.d.–behind.
There’s a knock on the door–the police are there to take Tom to the hospital where his wife has been admitted. She had a car accident, and lost control as she sped through the worst part of town.
General Thoughts
I was pretty disappointed in this book. I haven’t read any books by Shari Lapena before, but this book was on my to-read list for a while, and I know her other book The Couple Next Door got good reviews, so I had high expectations.
I personally wouldn’t recommend this book if you’re looking for a story that you really want to be absorbed in. I found that partway through I was debating not even finishing the story, but I forced myself to just in case there would be a twist that made it all worth it.
Well, there wasn’t.
Review – Spoilers Ahead!
First of all, let me just say that I didn’t connect to any of the characters at all. And I don’t need to relate to a character, or see myself in them to enjoy a book, either. But I just didn’t feel anything for the characters in this book. I found that I wasn’t super invested in the events of the story partially because I simply just did not care what happened to them. I found that I wasn’t hoping for certain characters to be innocent, or other characters to be guilty. I wasn’t fussed with what their fates would be either way.
I found that the story also felt quite small and predictable, in a way. It’s like the only people who existed in this world were the three main characters, and then the detectives and lawyer, who were even less interesting. None of the characters really made their mark – there wasn’t anything that brought them to life. And the fact that the story seemed to involve zero people from outside the small bubble made it feel much less real.
The story overall felt like a lot of telling and not showing. The characters were very clearly walking us through the story by just explaining their thoughts and worries the whole time, rather than us being able to interpret anything through their expressions or actions. We didn’t get to have a sense for the tension or the anxieties between the characters, we were basically just told how they felt. I don’t know, it just made it feel very mundane and like a lot of it could have been cut out. I wanted more plot and character development, not just internal dialogue. It felt like very little actually happened in the story, because it was mostly just one or two characters worrying about something.
It was also very confusing because it seemed like when the story was told from the cops perspective, it was meant to be a bit more mysterious like “oh no, what will they find when they search the house??”, but we already know because Brigid already had her own internal dialogue about snooping through their home and touching all their things. It felt like it was a bit out of order, like the cops should have searched the house and found Brigid’s fingerprints before she admitted to the reader that she snoops through the home. That way at least it could have created a bit more mystery around what evidence they might possibly find.
I also found that although some of the twists maybe weren’t ones that I saw coming, I still just…didn’t care about them. Or I wasn’t blown away by them, at least.
I was disappointed to find that the story was partially about a woman obsessed with her neighbour and in love with her neighbour’s husband. I feel like that was a really weak sub-plot that was kind of just inserted into the last bit of the novel in a rush. I didn’t find it to be that exciting of a twist because there was no evidence to look back on and go, “oh wow, she was trying to be Karen rather than trying to be friends with Karen”. I feel like that would have been developed better if she purchased the same perfume as Karen, or started subtly dressing like Karen throughout the book, and then it became gradually more and more obvious she was trying to transform into Karen.
Also, when it’s announced that Karen was never really abused…I feel like that also seemed a bit lazy in a way? I don’t know, I don’t get the point of adding in that element. Was it to try and make it seem like the book was about a powerful woman? It felt to me sort of like the author was trying to do a Gone Girl plot, where Karen is actually this genius mastermind able to expertly manipulate everyone around her into getting what she wants and believing the story she’s created. But it just felt so weak and half-hearted. If that’s the type of character she wanted to go with, then that’s the storyline that should have been developed. Not a storyline about a housewife with amnesia who doesn’t even know what actually happened.
The last attempt at a plot twist: Brigid is pregnant with Tom’s baby.
Honestly, at that point I was kind of over the whole novel, and that last plot twist just irritated me. I wasn’t upset on behalf of any of the characters, just annoyed that the story was still desperately trying to shock the reader when at that point, I personally just did not care about any of the characters enough to feel any kind of way about the pregnancy. I didn’t sit there feeling shocked or astounded, I didn’t wonder what that would mean for everyone, how Tom would react, I didn’t feel sorry for Karen or happy for Brigid. I was just like, “okay then,” and closed the book.
I’m not sure if I want to read The Couple Next Door now, as I’m worried it will be another letdown. If you have read it, let me know if it’s worth the read. And if you’ve read both books, let me know how The Couple Next Door compares to A Stranger in the House.
Until next time,
Nadine








































































